I came across this article that says that a panel of experts from the European Union (EU) has officially rejected Yakult’s health claim regarding its upper respiratory tract infection (URTI) benefits stemming from the consumption of Lactobacillus casei strain Shirota.
The panel, made up of a group of scientists from the European Food Safety Agency (EFSA)concludes that a cause and effect relationship has not been established between the consumption of Lactobacillus casei strain Shirota and maintenance of the upper respiratory tract defence against pathogens by maintaining immune defences. However, Yakult is undaunted by the EU’s statement stating their report has no bearing.
For more information, you can access the webpage at http://sg.entertainment.yahoo.com/news/yakult-overclaiming-says-eu-031926451.html
I thought that since we're doing our SOW and lesson plans pretty soon, we can download and keep this article for future use. As the issue stated involve a food product and covers some aspects of making informed consumer choices, we could perhaps use it as a case study questionfor our students when we teach the topic on Consumer Issues. It can also be an opportunity for students to debate on the relevance and accuracy of such a report and discuss ethics issues (if any) :)
I like your suggestion of using such articles as case studies for the students. Other than reinforcing consumer issues, it can also help to improve the students' scientific literacy skills which will be beneficial for them.
ReplyDeleteI do agree with you all to incorporate such articles into our lesson activity. Personally, I like to drink Yakult as it helps to improve digestion and it is really nice to drink! If want to compare with Vitagen, I still prefer Yakult as I feel that Vitagen has a chemical taste that maybe because it contains artificial colouring or what. I saw the Vitagen's advertisement claiming it has less sugar compared to other cultured drinks. I wonder if that is really the case?
ReplyDeleteWow! This is alarming, with the fact that we've been inculcated with the mindset since young that Yakult is good for health.
ReplyDeleteIn addition, Yakult is more expensive than Vitagen! So we should switch to Vitagen?
Personally, I feel that the conclusion should turn out to be the same for both 'healthy' drinks.